Share Ownership Questions and Big Losses Create Atlassian Stress Test – AFR – 4 August 2025

Atlassian's long-term unprofitability and venture-capital-like behaviour raise concerns, especially with a potential tech downturn and the rising costs of AI on the horizon.

Mike Cannon-Brookes has held a powerful voting stake in the software giant, equal to his co-founder Scott Farquhar’s. His divorce settlement might change that balance.

Interview by Paul Smith: Vendor analysis with Joseph Sweeney

Since its IPO, Atlassian has acted more like a venture capital fund than a traditional software vendor, funnelling cash into acquiring and building technology without a clear path to profitability. While it is not uncommon for growing tech companies to report non generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP) losses, Atlassian’s sustained unprofitability, spanning over 20 years, is a concern.

A key factor is the firm’s consistently high research and development (R&D) costs, which are greater than 50 per cent of its operating expenses. For a company with an established product set, these costs would be expected to decrease over time. This is especially concerning when rivals, such as ServiceNow, are profitable with comparable products and a smaller customer base. ServiceNow has a mature economic model and a solid AI strategy that leverages the broader market, acting more like a vendor of technology, while Atlassian behaves more like an investment house.

This approach is risky. With a potential downturn in the tech market, partly due to global economic headwinds and a ‘come-to-Jesus moment’ around AI vendor losses, Atlassian could find itself in a difficult position against its profitable rivals. The full costs of AI are not yet being passed on to customers, and an imminent recalibration will impact all vendors’ profitability.

Read the full story here.

Trouble viewing this article?

Search

Register for complimentary membership where you will receive:
  • Complimentary research
  • Free vendor analysis
  • Invitations to events and webinars
Delivered to your inbox each week